Congress apparently didn't read my article of April 7th, 2007 on the practical difficulties of 100 percent cargo inspection called for under House bill HR-1. HR-1 requires 100 percent cargo inspection of all air and ocean cargo. This week the bill passed through the US Senate and now awaits final language refinement prior to submission to President Bush for signature (or veto).This bill has good intention but is practically impossible to implement near term.
Forget that we don't have the current technology to perform the scanning. Forget that there is no clearly defined mandate for what's to be scanned. Forget that it will take a very long while to figure out the union rules on how this will take place.
The one concession I can see in the bill the Senate passed is that rather than completing implementation of this deal by the end of 2010, it has a 5 year implementation window with the ability of the Department of Homeland Security to extend the deadline 2 years.
What I am interested in is whether this will constitute a practical restraint of trade and a defacto tax on imports. Costs for inspection will find their way into the costs of goods. The practicality of the inspection activity will largely depend on quality of scanning, what we are specifically looking for, and how fast the scans can take place. If implemented tomorrow, it would gridlock our ports and strangle trade.
The ILWU and ILA work rules on how scanning will take place in ocean ports, as well as how it will be handled at airports will take some time to work out as well. Security is important to society. We need it. However, what is the economic impact of a 100 percent inspection? Once again I think reality and politics are at odds.
|
Add Freightdawg.com to your social bookmarks!


On Monday, July 23rd,
Its 1:10AM here in Atlanta on July 21st. I'm up because my 15 year old daughter and her aunt were out with the other Harry Potter crazies to get their hands on the last and latest Harry Potter book:
July 18th, 2007 -
There's a very interesting article available at 











Recent Comments