On Tuesday, July 27th, 2010, a Lufthansa MD-11 Freighter bound from Frankfurt, Germany to Riyadh, KSA crashed on landing destroying the air frame, however without loss of life. LH8460 was subsequently scheduled to fly from Riyadh to Sharjah then on to Hong Kong. Lufthansa only operates the MD-11 as a freighter.
The MD-11 suffers from a bad reputation given its few numbers built (200 aircraft). Of the 200 built, now 8 have crashed. Three of those were FedEx freighters. Compared to other wide body jets this number of crashes is very high.
Here are some comparisons to other aircraft currently flying.
- MD-11: 8 crashed out of 200
- B744: 3 crashed out of approximately 700 (166 pure freighters built)
- A340: 3 crashed out of approximately 390+
- B777: 1 crashed out of 860+
Previous MD-11 crashes are detailed here.
- 31-JUL-1997 MD-11F N611FE FedEx
- 02-SEP-1998 MD-11 HB-IWF Swissair
- 15-APR-1999 MD-11 HL7373 Korean Air
- 22-AUG-1999 MD-11 B-150 China Airlines
- 17-OCT-1999 MD-11F N581FE FedEx
- 23-MAR-2009 MD-11F N526FE FedEx
- 28-NOV-2009 MD-11F Z-BAV Avient
I'll be honest...if I was a FedEx pilot I'd be working on getting a rating to fly something else. I have friends who are Delta pilots who "inherited" the MD-11 when DAL purchased other airlines. There were always complaints that this aircraft was complicated to fly and was less-than-intuitive when it came to systems. Most were not unhappy to see these birds retired.
I will say as a passenger, I never liked the MD-11's older sister, the DC-10. When American had the horrific crash at Chicago ORD many years ago, that crash scared me. I always flew on the L-1011 because I thought it was a safer bird. The MD-11 is a derivative of the DC-10. Perhaps the recent crashes are not linked, but as a guy who rides in back...I pay attention.
Lufthansa is still sorting out the freight manifest for this flight and as far as I know, no losses have been formally confirmed to freight forwarders or shippers with freight aboard. That, I am sure is coming, but so far nothing has been put forward by the airline that I am aware of.
Eric












Recent Comments